Motivation, Relationships & Joy
Frame Forward
When something goes wrong, talk about the next move, so students start again instead of arguing
Use this when
What is it?
Frame Forward means talking about the next action rather than the failure that has just happened: "question two now" when ten minutes have gone missing, or "next lesson, the first five minutes will be different" after a dreadful one. The approach works because a next action gives students something to do immediately, while an account of what went wrong gives them something to argue with or go quiet over. The past still receives attention, in your planning and in private, but your public voice points towards what happens next.
The steps
- Name the next action before you speak. In the moment before you respond, decide the very next thing you want the student to do. If nothing comes to mind, take it from the task itself: the next question, or the next line to write.
- Say the action and when it starts. Keep it short and in the present tense. Add a time marker so that the restart has a deadline you can check:Question two now, full sentences. I'm back at this table in one minute.
- Say the best believable reason out loud. When you must refer to the lapse, attach the most generous explanation that could be true:I think you've forgotten how we start in here. Show me the first line.Choose a reading the student could accept in front of their friends.
- Write feedback as the next move. Turn your comment into a single instruction for the next attempt:Redraft paragraph two with the evidence included.In the next lesson, check the new version against that instruction.
- After a bad lesson, describe the better next one. Give the lesson itself one sentence at most, then spend the rest of your comment on the plan:That wasn't our best. Tomorrow we start with the quiz, first five minutes, and I think we'll be sharper.
- Keep a private place for the past. Log the pattern in your planner, keep any consequence that is due, and hold difficult conversations one to one. Study what went wrong in private, and bring only the plan back into the room.
What it looks like
Mrs Okonjo's history class of 14-year-olds is analysing trench letters, and the table by the radiator has three lines to show for ten minutes of work. She crosses the room with a speech about wasted time already forming in her head. "Right, you four. Source two now, one quotation each. I'm back at twenty past."
Then the old sentence starts to escape anyway: "Because so far you've…" She stops herself there. "Twenty past." Tyler picks up his pen. Amber begins "We weren't even…", finds no accusation to answer, and reads the source instead. At twenty past there are four quotations, one of them genuinely sharp. The last ten minutes are still scrappy. "Tomorrow we start with the map quiz, first five minutes. Bring today's sheet."
How you’ll know it’s working
- Corrections end at the action. From the back of the room you hear what happens next, and only occasionally a recap of what has just gone wrong.
- Restarts are quick. After a forward-facing line, most students are working again within about ten seconds, with no second exchange needed.
- Tally one lesson: your comments pointing towards the next action outnumber your comments about what has already happened.
- The lesson after a bad one opens with the plan you announced, and the first five minutes follow it.
Pitfalls & fixes
- Smuggling the past into the sentence. "Question two now, because you've wasted ten minutes" hands back the very argument you were avoiding, since students tend to answer the last clause they heard. End at the action and the time.
- Using it as an amnesty. Frame Forward changes how you talk about an incident; it does not cancel the consequence. If a detention is due, issue it quietly, then frame the return: "That's settled. Tomorrow I'd like your hand up first."
- A generous reading nobody believes. "You've probably forgotten" works early in a pattern; by the fifth time in a week it can sound like sarcasm, or like surrender. Once the charitable explanation stops being believable, switch to a quiet correction and a consequence (The Quiet Correction).
- Never looking back anywhere. If the past receives no attention at all, the same lesson tends to crash the same way the following week. Hold the post-mortem in your planner or in a private conversation, and bring the plan back to the class.
Weigh it up
Why it’s worth it
- Lost minutes stop multiplying. A next action can put students back to work within seconds, while an inquest into the lost ten minutes costs several more of them.
- Fewer corrections become battles. Because no accusation is made, there is nothing to argue with, and a student who would fight a telling-off will often simply do the next thing.
- Written feedback is more likely to be acted on. An instruction for the next attempt can be checked against the redraft, which turns marking time into changed work.
- Your praise starts to land again. Students tend to discount warm words from a voice they mostly hear complaining; once your public voice points forward, acknowledgement and praise regain their value (Precise Praise).
- Bad lessons stop carrying over. Ending a poor lesson with the plan for a better one means that you and the class both arrive expecting it, and expectancy research suggests students drift towards what teachers visibly expect.
The costs
- The backward-facing sentence is the natural one. Expect to catch yourself halfway through it for several weeks, sometimes audibly.
- The past still needs a home. Logging patterns, planning the reteaching and holding private conversations all take extra discipline that the forward frame does not supply.
- After a serious incident, forward-only talk can come across as minimising. Students need to see the matter taken seriously before a fresh start means anything.
Adaptations
- Early years / lower primary: keep the frame seconds long and physical: "Hands in laps, then I choose the story." A carpet resets more quickly on a next action than on any account of the fidgeting.
- Primary: declare fresh starts out loud and often. An afternoon can begin again: "New afternoon. Spellings first, and table three, I'd like you to start us off."
- Secondary: keep the generous reading brief and believable, because teenagers tend to screen everything for sarcasm. Frame written feedback as marks still available: "Two more marks live in paragraph two. Add the evidence."
- Post-16 / adult: use it for missed deadlines and patchy attendance, delivered in a workplace register: "The essay is now due Friday. Bring the plan on Wednesday and I'll check it with you."
Where this comes from
Doug Lemov codified this territory in Teach Like a Champion as part of Positive Framing, including the moves he calls "live in the now" and "assume the best"; solution-focused approaches in coaching and pastoral work have long asked about the next small step rather than the causes of the problem. Frame Forward is this library's name for the classroom core of those ideas. The nearest research concerns teacher expectancy, which finds that students tend to move towards what teachers visibly expect, although the famous study is contested and the specific move has not been trialled, so this page is graded as craft.
Sources
Related techniques
Ratings & discussion
Ratings loading…