Silent Start Writing
Give short, regular, unmarked writing bursts, so starting to write stops being the hard part
What is it?
Silent Start Writing is a short, regular burst of writing: a few minutes in silence, the pen moving the whole time, with nothing marked afterwards. The routine works because starting is often the hardest part of writing, and the burst gives students a safe start to practise several times a week. Its job is building fluency; when you want writing aimed at a question before a discussion, that is Everybody Writes.
The steps
- Choose a prompt anyone can start. Early on, keep prompts open: a memory, a place, an opinion, a picture on the board. Later, once the class writes freely, point some bursts at your topic.
- Teach the rules, then set a visible timer. Give the rules in the same words each time.When I say go, your pen keeps moving until the timer sounds. If you get stuck, write 'I'm stuck, I'm stuck' until the next thought arrives. No rubbing out, no crossing out, and spelling can wait. Nobody reads this unless you choose. Four minutes. Go.Keep the rules on display so that you can point to them later. Set the timer for three or four minutes, placed where everyone can see it.
- Write your own burst for the first minute. Sit where the class can see your pen moving. Writing alongside them shows that the burst is real work, and it stops you hovering. After your minute, look up and watch for stopped pens. Go to a writer who has stopped and point quietly at the stuck rule. Leave the page unread.
- Stop on time and count words. When the timer sounds, say "pens down" and wait for full quiet. Ask everyone to count their words and write the number in the margin. That number is a private score to beat next time. Invite one or two volunteers to read a single line aloud.
- Run it two or three times a week. Keep the same rules, the same length and, where you can, the same slot. The gains come from doing it often, so expect several weeks before the change shows in ordinary written work.
- Build the bridge to judged writing. Every two or three weeks, ask the class to reread their bursts.Read back through your last few bursts. Circle one line that deserves a better sentence. We'll grow it into today's draft.Let the circled line become the seed of a piece of writing you will mark.
What it looks like
It is Tuesday, period two, and Miss Duffield's English class of 12-year-olds knows the routine. The prompt is on the board: a place I know with my eyes shut. "Four minutes. Pens moving the whole time. Go." The room settles to the scratch of pens.
Thirty seconds in, Kian has stopped, his arm curled around his page. She crouches beside him. "Stuck? Then write I'm stuck until something arrives. Keep the pen moving." He writes it twice, and then a third line appears: the smell of my nan's hallway. When the timer sounds she says, "Pens down. Count your words and put the number in the margin." She asks who beat last Tuesday's number, and a dozen hands go up. Amara announces fifty-three, eleven more than last week. Nobody has to read aloud, and the books close.
How you’ll know it’s working
- Pens are moving within about ten seconds of "go", including those of the students who used to lose the first five minutes of any written task.
- The margin counts climb: a student who managed thirty words in the first week is often past sixty after six weeks.
- The freeze shortens elsewhere: when you set ordinary written work, the gap between the instruction and the first word narrows across the room.
- More students volunteer to read a line aloud: none in the first week, then a handful within a month.
Pitfalls & fixes
- Marking the bursts. A corrected spelling breaks the promise, and careful, short writing returns. Keep the pages unread unless a student offers them; if your school scrutinises books, label these pages as fluency practice.
- A prompt only some can start. A question that requires particular knowledge recreates the freeze for the students you most want writing. Keep early prompts open to any writer, and save topic prompts until the class writes fluently.
- Letting the burst stretch. Ten minutes of forced writing can turn the routine into a slog. Stop at three to five minutes, while most students still have something left to say.
- Running it only when time allows. A burst every second week trains very little. Plan two or three a week in the same slot, and protect them as you would any other routine.
Weigh it up
Why it’s worth it
- The freeze shrinks. After weeks of practised starts, students tend to begin ordinary written tasks sooner, in your subject and beyond it.
- Writing lengthens everywhere. The stamina built in the bursts carries over into normal answers, and two thin lines slowly become a paragraph.
- It costs no marking. The books stay closed, so the fluency gains arrive without claiming a single evening of your time.
- It settles a room. Run as the lesson opener, a familiar silent burst calms the class before you teach, and it slots naturally into a Do Now.
- Weak writers get a winnable score. The private word count gives students who rarely win at writing a number that rises week after week.
The costs
- The payoff is slow. You spend ten to fifteen minutes a week for much of a term before the fluency appears in ordinary work.
- The writing itself is disposable. Most bursts never become anything more, and you have to accept pages of unmarked, unpolished writing in the books.
- The silence is a routine of its own. In a class that cannot yet hold quiet, bursts turn into whispering, so the quiet routine has to come first.
Adaptations
- Early years / lower primary: make it a minute of drawing and labelling, keeping the same rule that the pencil keeps moving. Count labels rather than words.
- Primary: two or three minutes suits most 8-to-11-year-olds. Sometimes count a class total rather than individual scores, so that slower writers still watch a number climb.
- Secondary: point some bursts at content once fluency arrives. "Write everything you can about the causes of the war" turns the burst into retrieval, close to a Brain Dump, and a burst before essay planning helps to loosen ideas.
- Post-16 / adult: use the tradition's own name, freewriting, and explain where it comes from. Five minutes suits adults, and a private journal often works better than an exercise book.
Where this comes from
Peter Elbow codified freewriting in Writing Without Teachers in 1973, and timed, unjudged bursts have been a staple of writing classrooms ever since. Doug Lemov's Teach Like a Champion 3.0 includes a close classroom cousin in 'Silent Solo'. The research base is thin: writing-to-learn studies find modest gains from writing about content, but the fluency burst has not been trialled on its own.
Sources
Related techniques
Ratings & discussion
Ratings loading…