One Great Sentence
Swap the paragraph for one sentence written to a high standard, then improve it together
Use this when
What is it?
One Great Sentence replaces a paragraph task with a single sentence written to a high standard: drafted in silence, compared, improved together and then redrafted. A constraint such as "use 'although' in the middle" directs the thinking, and because the task is so small, every choice inside the sentence can receive real attention. Students who learn to control single sentences tend to carry that control into everything longer they write.
The steps
- Pick the idea and set one constraint. Choose the idea at the heart of the lesson, then add one structural demand:use 'although' in the middle, "start with the clause that cannot stand alone", "include both key terms". A good constraint forces the logic of the content into the shape of the sentence.
- Set the task and name the standard. Tell the class it is one sentence only, and state exactly what it must contain.One sentence, no more. It must explain why the treaty caused resentment, and 'although' must sit in the middle. Take the full three minutes and make it the best sentence you write this week.
- Give two or three minutes of silent drafting. Circulate while students write, and note two candidates for sharing: one strong, one nearly there.
- Share the candidates without names. Write both on the board or project them, then ask the class precise questions about each.Look at the first one. What is the 'although' doing in that sentence? Is it earning its place?
- Improve one sentence with the class. Take the nearly-there candidate and redraft it on the board, saying each new version aloud before making the next change.
- Have everyone redraft. Students rewrite their own sentence in the light of what they have just heard. This second version goes in the book.
What it looks like
Mrs Sefton's class of 14-year-olds has spent the lesson on the Treaty of Versailles. Ten minutes before the end she sets the task: "One sentence explaining why the treaty caused such resentment in Germany, with 'although' in the middle. Three minutes, in silence." She circulates, then writes two candidate sentences on the board without names. The first reads: The treaty caused resentment although it was harsh. The class nods; it contains 'although'.
She reads it aloud slowly and waits. Femi frowns. "The 'although' part should push against the other part. That one agrees with itself." Together they rebuild it: Although the Allies called it a peace settlement, many Germans experienced the treaty as a punishment. Everyone redrafts their own sentence. Marta's second version swaps 'was made to pay' for 'was blamed and billed', and Mrs Sefton reads it to the class twice.
How you’ll know it’s working
- Drafting time stays silent, and nearly every student has a complete sentence when you call time. Count the books: aim for a full sentence from at least 25 of 30 students within three minutes.
- Second drafts differ from first drafts. Spot-check five books: most should show a changed clause or word choice, with no sentences simply copied out again.
- Discussion of the shared candidates names parts of the sentence: the clause, the verb, the connective, rather than "it flows better".
- The constrained structures begin to reappear in ordinary written work within weeks, unprompted: 'although' sentences turning up in an essay you never scaffolded.
Pitfalls & fixes
- A constraint that decorates rather than forces. "Include an adjective" tends to produce ornament. Constrain the logic instead: a connective that carries cause or concession, or both key terms in one clause.
- Stopping after the first draft. A single sentence written once is just a short answer. The comparing and redrafting carry most of the learning, so protect the last five minutes for them.
- Sharing only polished sentences. A parade of perfect work teaches admiration, while nobody learns how to revise. Choose one nearly-there sentence, keep it anonymous and improve it in front of everyone.
- Letting it sprawl into a paragraph. Students bolt on a second sentence to say what the first could not hold. Hold the limit, and ask what the single sentence must lose in order to carry the whole idea.
Weigh it up
Why it’s worth it
- Every student writes and every student redrafts. Thirty versions of the same idea reach you within ten minutes, each one a sample of understanding.
- Sentence control tends to transfer upward. Structures practised here, subordinate clauses and precise connectives, begin appearing in paragraphs and essays without being asked for.
- One sentence is a small ask. Students who freeze at a paragraph will usually attempt it, and the constraint tells them how to begin.
- The redrafting is feedback with no marking attached. The work improves during the lesson, while it still matters to the writer, and nothing goes home in your bag.
- A well-chosen constraint doubles as a check for understanding: a student who cannot place 'although' in the middle has usually not grasped the tension in the content.
The costs
- Great sentences do not join themselves into great paragraphs. You still have to teach the joining, and a diet of single sentences alone would cap extended writing.
- Good constraints take planning. A vague one wastes the routine, and writing a sharp one for each new topic is a skill that develops slowly.
- The full routine takes eight to ten minutes of lesson time. Used more than once or twice in a lesson, it begins to crowd out the extended writing it is meant to feed.
Adaptations
- Early years / lower primary: craft the sentence aloud together before anyone writes. You scribe on the board while the class suggests improvements, and everyone copies the final version and reads it back.
- Primary: draft on show-me boards (mini whiteboards) so that you can see thirty sentences at once and choose candidates in seconds. Keep to one constraint at a time; 'because' in the middle is plenty.
- Secondary: take the constraint from the discipline. History rewards 'although'; science often needs 'as a result of'; in maths, try "if… then…" with both conditions stated.
- Post-16 / exam classes: aim the routine at the sentences examiners reward: a thesis sentence, or an evaluation shaped as "Although X, Y, because Z". Craft one together, then open the essay with it.
Where this comes from
The sentence-first tradition in writing instruction reaches back decades through sentence-combining research. Judith Hochman and Natalie Wexler put the sentence at the centre of a whole method in The Writing Revolution, and Doug Lemov codified a one-sentence classroom routine as 'Art of the Sentence' in Teach Like a Champion. The research case for sentence-level teaching is real; this specific draft, share and redraft routine has not been trialled on its own.
Sources
Related techniques
Ratings & discussion
Ratings loading…