Set How They'll Answer
Say how each question will be answered before you ask it, so calling out fades
What is it?
Set How They'll Answer means announcing the answering format before you ask each question: hands up, cold call, pairs, boards or everybody writes. Students then know whether to raise a hand, pick up a pen or wait to be named, so nobody is left guessing. Once every question has a declared channel, calling out tends to fade, because a shout is no longer the only way to be heard.
The steps
- Teach the labels in one short briefing. Tell the class which formats you use and what each label asks of them. A minute is usually enough.Before every question, I'll say how we're answering it. 'Hands' means hands up. 'Cold call' means I choose, so hands stay down. 'Boards' means write it. 'Pairs' means tell your partner. If I haven't said yet, we're still thinking.
- Choose the format as you plan each question. Match the format to the job the question is doing. A short, checkable answer suits boards. A question that needs a reason suits pairs. Cold call lets you hear one student's thinking in full, while hands up shows you who wants to offer. Add "everybody writes" once you want full sentences from everyone.
- Say the label before the question, every time. Give the label, leave a beat, then ask the question:Cold call. Why does the poet repeat 'again'?The beat gives pens time to lift or hands time to settle.
- Run the format exactly as usual. The label simply hands over to the routine you have already taught: think time for cold call, the timer for pairs, "show me" for boards.
- Take answers through the named format only. When an answer is shouted out on a hands question, redirect it warmly and hold the format.Good thinking, but this one's hands. Put it up and I'll come to you.
- Vary the formats across the lesson. A sequence might run boards, boards, cold call, pairs, hands. The variety keeps the class listening for each label and gives each question the kind of check it needs.
What it looks like
Miss Odedra's class of 11-year-olds is practising French adjectives. "Boards for this one: 'the black cat'. Write it, keep it hidden." Pens lift. "Three, two, one: show me." Most boards read le chat noir; two read le noir chat, and she sorts out the word order with the whole class. "Cold call next. Why does noir come after chat?" Hands stay down while she waits, then: "…Kofi?" He explains.
Twenty minutes later, in full flow, she asks "So what happens with a feminine noun?" without a label, and three voices answer at once. She stops. "My fault. I didn't say how we were answering. That one was boards. On your boards: 'the black door'. Keep it hidden." Pens lift again, and this time the room stays silent until the cue.
How you’ll know it’s working
- Pens lift at "boards" and hands settle at "cold call" before the question has even been asked.
- A tally of call-outs across ten questions falls week by week, often from double figures to one or two.
- Nobody asks "do we put our hands up?", because the label has already answered it.
- An observer at the back of the room could name the answering format of every question in the lesson from the label alone.
Pitfalls & fixes
- The label after the question. By the time you say "hands", the answer has already been shouted out. Say the label first; if you forget, stop, name the format and ask the question again.
- Accepting the shouted answer anyway. One brilliant call-out accepted on a hands question teaches the class that the labels are decoration. Redirect it warmly, then take the same answer through the format.
- Too many labels, loosely worded. "Boards", "whiteboards" and "show me" used for the same format blur into noise. Stick to three to five formats, with one fixed word for each.
- Losing the labels at pace. Fast follow-up exchanges go unannounced, and the call-outs begin to creep back in. For a rapid sequence, set the format once: "Cold call until I say otherwise."
Weigh it up
Why it’s worth it
- Calling out fades without confrontation. Every question has a declared channel, so a shouted answer needs a three-word redirect rather than a behaviour conversation, and the tone of the room stays warm.
- Thinking time survives. Until the format opens, no answer can land, so nobody's thinking is cut short because a quicker classmate got the answer out first.
- It sharpens your planning. Choosing a format makes you decide what each question is for: a check on everyone, a rehearsal in pairs, or one student's reasoning heard in full. Questions without a clear job tend to get cut.
- Your existing routines get sharper. Boards questions begin with pens already up, pair discussions start within seconds, and being cold called feels expected because the label came first.
- It is nearly free. It costs two or three words in front of each question, needs no kit and no marking, and you can start in your next lesson.
The costs
- The consistency is yours to supply. Expect to forget the labels mid-lesson for the first week or two, and expect each lapse to invite the calling out back in.
- A label only means something once the format behind it has been taught. "Pairs" names nothing until partners have been assigned, and "boards" needs a working boards routine first.
- A fully channelled room can lose some of the eager energy that certain classes run on. If you value that buzz, give it a legitimate outlet such as Call & Response.
Adaptations
- Early years / lower primary: pair each label with a gesture or a picture card as you say it, and keep to two or three formats. "Hands" with a raised hand; "partner" with two fingers pressed together.
- Primary: rehearse the labels as a one-minute game in the first week. Call "boards", "hands" and "pairs" in random order with no questions attached, and watch the room respond to each.
- Secondary: largely unchanged. Add "everybody writes" once answers need full sentences, and expect to hold the line longest with a class whose other lessons permit calling out.
- Post-16 / adult: drop the classroom labels and fold the format into ordinary speech: "Talk to your neighbour first", "Jot an answer down", "Anyone, call it out." A deliberate call-it-out question works well with adults.
Where this comes from
Doug Lemov named this move 'Means of Participation' in Teach Like a Champion 3.0, and less formal versions of it are long-standing practice in any classroom that runs several answering formats side by side. The research behind it is context rather than proof: studies of effective teachers show them involving every student in answering, but announcing the format before each question has not been trialled on its own.
Sources
Related techniques
Ratings & discussion
Ratings loading…